Brazil’s Supreme Court Agrees To Hold Social Media Companies Liable For Unethical And Illegal User Content
Brazil’s Supreme Court justices have set a new standard, with a majority of them all agreeing to hold social media companies accountable for illegal and unethical postings by their users. This move was made during a time where social media is so vast that there’s a large population of users that are able to get away with posting illegal content without being punished.
The court made a ruling on two different cases in order to reach this understanding. The rise in reports from social media companies containing posts that involve fraud, violence among underage individuals, and child pornography.
Critics are claiming that this move could infringe on users freedom of speech, which is one of the biggest reasons that social media platforms struggle when it comes to censoring or removing content and reporting users.
To combat the freedom of speech argument, the court has moved to hold the companies as a whole liable for the content, rather than just the individual poster. According to AP, Gilmar Mended became the sixth of the court’s 11 justices to vote for companies such as Meta, X, and Microsoft to be sued and pay fines for illegal content.
While the voting is still ongoing, having a basic majority is all that’s needed for the overall measure to pass.
Justice André Mendonça has been the only dissenting voice so far, stating that “free speech on social media is key for the publication of information that holds powerful public institutions to account, including governments, political elites and digital platforms.”
Justice Flávio Dino cited recent cases in which school shootings in Brazil were simulated on social media and read out posts from a user who stated he was “happy watching families of dead children weeping, bleeding, dying.”
“I think social media has not made humanity closer to what it has produced in best fashion,” he said.
This proposal can become law once the voting is finalized, however, Brazil’s Congress could pass a law to reverse the measure. Current legislation in Brazil says that social media companies can only be held liable if they do not remove content after a court order.
“Platforms need to be pro-active in regulating content. They need to adopt certain precautions that are not compatible with simply waiting for a judge to eventually issue a decision ordering the removal of that content,” said Alvaro Palma de Jorge, a law professor at the Rio-based Getulio Vargas Foundation.
Eric Mastrota is a Contributing Editor at The National Digest based in New York. A graduate of SUNY New Paltz, he reports on world news, culture, and lifestyle. You can reach him at eric.mastrota@thenationaldigest.com.



